Domestic violence results are in...


06.25.04 (7:30 pm)   [edit]

Domestic violence results are in...

Has anyone else received the latest Johnny W booklet? “Violence Against Women – Australia Says No”
Apparently I missed the referendum…
But enough jokes. I was at Mum and Dad’s yesterday and Mum told me that part of the reason the campaign was postponed was because it contained stuff about emotional violence. Apparently Johnny W didn’t like that too much, so he made them go back and change it so that people wouldn’t have to start thinking about violence within any new frames of reference. I suppose at the time he must have thought that emotional violence was okay because sometimes you have to use it gain military information. To the campaign’s credit though, the booklet (which my household did not receive) does contain a lot of stuff about emotional violence, coercion etc.
I wonder how much it makes a difference. Does the sort of person who psychologically dominates their girlfriend 1) read government information booklets and 2) think it applies to them?
Physical violence is bad enough and the TV ads do a fairly good job of conveying how grey the issue can be (ie. “I don’t hit her, it’s just shoving and that”). But I think a few other ‘stories’ are in order. For example: “She pisses me off so much and I have to yell at her to get the message through. Then she quietens down.” or “He said he’d belt me one if I stayed out late with the girls again”. The serious masculine voice over man would then say “Threats of physical violence are still classed as assault in the eyes of the law.” Or maybe that’s too many syllables.
I also can’t help thinking of where men fit into domestic violence stats. Thanks to the campaign, it’s common knowledge that women are the majority of victims and that too many assaults go unreported. But I wonder how many men are victims of domestic violence? And how does it happen? Why? Under what circumstances? I find it hard to imagine the Andy Cap cliché of the wife in rollers and dressing gown waiting for her boozed up husband with a frying pan. In real life a drunken husband coming home to an aggressive would be statistically more likely to be the one doing the assaulting (or, to quote my hero Homer, ‘Ah, Andy Cap, you wife-beating drunk’).
I don’t suppose my questions will be answered any time soon …


posted by: Penny Ryan (reply)
post date: 06.29.04 (9:51 pm)

The thing that I respond to most about the booklet is the lack of stories from the point of view of men who have started to look at their own behaviour or of men around them - i have been to a lot of good men's groups who have been coming to terms with their own behaviours and how they got that way and I know that these can make a difference - but thebooklet doesn't deal at all with the process of change for men and boys... this is a complete lost opportunity and seems to me to reflect a failure to udnerstand where violence comes from - ie it isn't inherent in men itws a learned and culturally reinforced thing and can be unlearned. There is only one story in the whole booklet that even vaguely gives men a hand in this stuff - why not more if we actually want to change this?



posted by: Franzy (reply)
post date: 06.30.04 (1:41 am)

I knew I was feeling disenfranchised - I just couldn't figure out why. This is an excellent point. The whole approach of the campaign is almost reminiscent of the way the libs seem to view a lot of stuff that isn't white and 'normal'. Like saying "Just change your sexuality", "just stop being poor" and "just go and earn money". "Just don't hit women" should be that simple but it's not. The same kerfuffle was around earlier this year with the footy players and their pack raping. Does it still go on? Probably.



posted by: Franzy (reply)
post date: 06.30.04 (7:14 am)

Another thought - perhaps it shows the same respect for the intellectual capabilities of Australians as the fact that they removed any reference to emotional violence from the TV ad. Maybe they thought we just wouldn't get more than one idea at a time...

Your Name:


Your Comment: